Back to work
Oracle CX Marketing · Internship

Governance Solution
in Fusion Marketing

A granular governance system that balances enterprise guardrails with AI-empowered creative freedom — so marketing teams can move fast without breaking the brand.

Timeline
3 Months
Role
Sole UX Designer
Tools
Figma
Company & Team
Oracle · CX Marketing
Governance Solution in Fusion Marketing — Email Template Editor

01 — The Challenge

A Brand at Risk

In large-scale B2B marketing, maintaining brand consistency is a constant battle. Senior Marketers must guarantee all communications align with brand standards — but the tools gave them no real enforcement mechanism.

Meanwhile, Junior Marketers were overwhelmed by complex tooling, often creating off-brand content or abandoning the platform entirely. Internal Oracle marketing teams had even started building proprietary tools because Fusion Marketing's governance features were inadequate.

Three Core Gaps

  • Limited Template Locking The platform offered minimal locking controls — no way to protect brand-critical elements at the attribute level.
  • No Asset Enforcement No mechanism to enforce image or asset guidelines, letting off-brand visuals slip through unchecked.
  • Outdated UI An aging interface made features hard to discover, pushing users toward workarounds instead of native tools.
The Goal

Design a governance solution within Oracle Fusion Marketing that allows Senior Marketers to set guardrails (constraints) while empowering Junior Marketers to launch campaigns quickly — without sacrificing brand compliance.

02 — Research

Audits and Competitive Tension

I started with a deep audit of Oracle's existing Eloqua platform, then analyzed 11 competitors to understand the landscape — and where Oracle's approach diverged.

Existing Eloqua email canvas — limited constraint controls

The existing Eloqua canvas — constraint controls buried in a side panel with limited locking granularity.

Competitive analysis of 11 email marketing platforms

Competitive analysis across 11 platforms — 72% used a sidebar, 81% were unlocked by default.

What the Market Does

72% of competitors placed lock controls in a sidebar. 81% defaulted to an unlocked state — giving Junior Marketers full freedom and requiring Senior Marketers to lock elements manually.

Initial Strategy

Following industry patterns, the initial plan mirrored this approach: maintain an open canvas and let Senior Marketers manually lock individual elements. This would soon need to be challenged.

03 — Users

Two Users, One System

Without direct customer access, I worked closely with product managers to build a clear picture of the two primary user types and their often-conflicting needs.

User personas: Marketing Specialist and Field Marketer
Clarity of Purpose — user goals for Marketing Specialist and Field Marketer

Clarity of Purpose — each user's primary goal shapes a fundamentally different relationship with the template system.

Senior Marketer (Marketing Specialist)

Sets policies and constraints on what Field Marketers can or can't do when creating emails. Needs confidence that brand standards are enforced — without reviewing every send manually.

Junior Marketer (Field Marketer)

Creates emails using a "constrained" version of the canvas. Needs speed and simplicity — launching on-brand campaigns quickly across platforms without needing deep design expertise.

04 — Information Architecture

Taming the Complexity

The biggest information architecture challenge: how do you present dozens of lockable attributes — margins, font sizes, colors, padding — without overwhelming users into paralysis?

The solution was a three-pillar framework that grouped every email attribute into high-level "buckets," enabling both rapid governance and surgical precision.

Three-pillar grouping framework: Layout, Style, Content

Layout, Style, and Content — three master categories that became the backbone of the constraint system.

Layout
The structural skeleton — components, blocks, and overall layout arrangement.
Style
The visual look and feel — fonts, text decoration, alignment, background colors, cell padding, borders.
Content
The actual message substance — text copy, images, and buttons.

05 — Exploration

Lo-Fi to Hi-Fi

Weeks 5–6 were about divergence — exploring the solution space broadly before committing to any direction. I tested sidebar placement for lock controls, following the 72% industry standard, with an "Unlocked by Default" mental model.

Lo-fi wireframes for AI content generation panel

Early wireframes exploring sidebar lock controls and the AI content generation panel.

Lo-fi template selection flow

Lo-fi template selection flow for Junior Marketers — choosing a constrained template to start from.

AI Integration — Week 3

Midway through the project, scope expanded to incorporate Generative AI capabilities. I designed a new left-panel for GenAI copy generation and an "AI Image" replacement feature — enabling Junior Marketers to generate brand-relevant assets instantly, without leaving the canvas.

06 — The Pivot

Designing for Context,
Not Trends

At week 7, I presented the high-fidelity "Unlocked by Default" prototype to stakeholders. The feedback was a turning point.

The Reality Check

Stakeholders pointed out that in an enterprise context, a Junior Marketer's primary goal is speed and compliance — not total creative freedom. Junior Marketers rarely needed structural changes. Open templates meant Senior Marketers had to lock every element individually — an enormous manual burden.

The Full Reversal

The entire system logic flipped. Instead of "Unlocked by Default" with manual locking, the system became "Locked by Default." Senior Marketers would now intentionally allow editing for specific sections — a far lighter lift that aligned with how enterprise governance actually works.

Before: Open canvas with no constraints

Before — open canvas, no governance.

V1: Unlocked by default with manual locking

V1 — unlocked by default, sidebar locking.

Final: Locked by default with allowed editing

Final — locked by default, senior allows editing.

07 — The Solution

Granular Control & Intelligence

The final design introduced a streamlined "Save as Template" workflow with two-tiered governance — from high-level category toggles down to individual element locks — plus a GenAI assistant operating within brand guardrails.

Saving an email as a constrained template

Senior Marketers save any email as a template, triggering the constraint configuration flow.

01

Save as Template

Senior Marketers begin by saving a completed email as a template. This triggers a dedicated constraint configuration flow where they define exactly what Field Marketers can and cannot change — without touching a single lock icon manually.

Setting high-level and granular constraints on a template

High-level category toggles first, then granular per-element locks for surgical control.

02

Two-Tiered Governance

The constraint panel operates at two levels:

  • High-level: Checkboxes allow or restrict editing for entire categories — Email Content, Email Style, Email Layout
  • Granular: Individual lock icons next to every attribute — background, text, padding, border — for precise control
Junior Marketer selecting a template and editing within constraints

Junior Marketers see a simplified canvas — only the elements they're permitted to edit are interactive.

03

The Junior Marketer Experience

When a Field Marketer opens a constrained template, the canvas reflects only what they can change. Locked elements are visually distinct — no confusion, no accidental edits, no brand violations. Speed is preserved because they're not fighting the tool.

AI-powered on-brand image selection for Junior Marketers

Junior Marketers choose from a pre-approved batch of on-brand images — curated by the Senior Marketer.

04

GenAI Within Guardrails

A left-panel GenAI assistant lets Field Marketers generate copy and swap images — but only within the boundaries the Senior Marketer has defined. On-brand AI image generation pulls from an approved asset library, so creativity never comes at the cost of compliance.

AI Generate content panel

GenAI copy generation — prompt-based content creation within the canvas.

AI image replacement with brand-approved assets

AI image replacement — pulling from the Senior Marketer's approved asset library.

08 — Reflection

What I learned

The project was successfully handed to the development team at the end of the 12-week internship. While long-term metrics were unavailable, stakeholder validation confirmed the "Locked by Default" approach better served enterprise governance needs.

01
Clarity of Purpose
Always design for the specific user's use case — even if it contradicts industry-standard trends. The 81% "Unlocked by Default" benchmark was accurate for the market, but wrong for Oracle's enterprise context where compliance matters more than creative freedom. Data informs, but context decides.
02
Zoom Out
It's easy to get lost in the details of a sidebar UI. Regularly stepping back to look at the full "Hero's Journey" — the marketer's end-to-end workflow — was essential. The pivot to "Locked by Default" only became obvious when I stopped obsessing over individual lock icons and looked at what each user actually needed to accomplish.
03
Constraints Enable Creativity
Counterintuitively, a tighter system made Junior Marketers more creative — not less. By removing the anxiety of "what can I break?" the constrained canvas let them focus entirely on crafting the message. Good governance isn't a cage; it's a foundation.
04
Stakeholder Feedback as a Feature
The week 7 pivot was uncomfortable — significant hi-fi work needed rethinking. But the reversal ultimately produced a stronger, more grounded solution. Learning to treat late-stage feedback as course correction rather than failure made me a more resilient designer.
Next Case Study
Mobile Production
Reporting
Oracle SCM Smart Operations
View Case Study